Skip to main content
70 %
A19 I0066

Commercial property investment is often misunderstood as a game of timing. Attempting to perfectly predict market peaks and troughs is rarely successful. What separates consistent performers from speculative players is not timing but a deep understanding of how property cycles operate, especially within the neighbourhood shopping centre sector, where tenant quality and income security underpin long-term value.

Commercial property cycles follow a broad pattern of four key phases: recovery, expansion, hypersupply, and recession. While each phase has its nuances, certain themes consistently reappear; tenant strength, lease length, and sustainable yields.

Commercial property markets move in recurring cycles influenced by macroeconomic conditions, investor sentiment, supply-demand dynamics, and access to capital. Understanding these cycles as investors and asset managers allows us to develop strategies suited to each phase, rather than reacting to short-term fluctuations.

1. Recovery – When the market begins to stabilise after a downturn

  • Vacancies begin to decline
  • Rental rates stabilise or slowly increase
  • Capital values start to recover
  • Investor confidence cautiously returns
  • Minimal new supply enters the market


The recovery phase is often marked by opportunity. Asset prices may still reflect the recent downturn, but underlying fundamentals such as tenant demand and consumer activity begin to improve. Investors with a forward-looking approach can acquire well-located assets below replacement cost or at favourable yield spreads. Savills Australia (2023) reported neighbourhood shopping centres traded at average yields of 6.1% during early recovery phases, compared to 5.3% at market peaks.


Importantly, risk-adjusted returns are typically higher during this phase as competition for assets remains low. This is a suitable time to increase portfolio exposure through disciplined acquisitions, provided due diligence confirms improving fundamentals.

2. Expansion – Rising rents, declining vacancies, and investor confidence return

  • Strong tenant demand and falling vacancies
  • Rents rise at an accelerating pace
  • Capital values increase in line with income growth
  • Development activity ramps up
  • Increased investor demand and transaction volumes


Confidence returns to the market during expansion. Property values rise in response to stronger income and lower risk perception. New investors such as institutional investors or offshore capital often return to the market, driving yields lower and increasing asset competition.


During expansion, investors benefit from income growth and asset appreciation. It is also a prime time for enhancing existing assets through re-leasing, rent reviews, or capital works. However, caution should be exercised as increasing development activity may eventually lead to oversupply.



3. Hypersupply – New developments outpace demand, leading to increased vacancy

  • New developments exceed actual tenant demand
  • Vacancy rates begin to rise
  • Rental growth slows or reverses
  • Tenant incentives increase
  • Yield compression slows or reverses


This phase is often driven by developers, lenders, and investors extrapolating past growth and overestimating future demand. The resulting oversupply places downward pressure on rents and occupancy levels, and previously strong returns begin to moderate.


This is a time to exercise caution and scrutinise tenant retention risk, maintain strong leasing relationships, and ensure portfolios are not exposed to high-vacancy risk. Speculative development or aggressive acquisitions during this phase may result in underperformance.

4. Recession – Declining rents and values, investor sentiment weakens

  • Demand for space declines
  • Vacancies rise significantly
  • Rents fall or stagnate
  • Asset values decline
  • Financing becomes more difficult or expensive
  • Market sentiment turns cautious or pessimistic


This phase typically reflects the low point in the market cycle, driven by broader economic downturns or sector-specific corrections. Investor activity slows, capital becomes scarce, and transactional liquidity weakens.


Capital preservation becomes paramount. With a focus on assets with strong WALE’s and resilient income profiles. Defensive asset classes such as neighbourhood shopping centres anchored by essential-service tenants can outperform during this phase due to their stable cash flow and continued consumer demand. During COVID-19, essential-service neighbourhood centres retained rent collection rates above 90%, while discretionary retail dropped below 65% (Urbis, 2021).


While the environment is challenging, the recession phase can also present contrarian opportunities for long-term investors able to acquire distressed or under-valued assets and position themselves for the next recovery phase.

07 18 03 01 220216 CH SA Brickworks 01 Interiors 0354

Cycle-Specific Risk Anchors

Rather than applying a blanket approach to risk, we adjust our strategy at each stage of the cycle. Our approach emphasises:

  • Tenant Strength: Anchor tenants in essential services provide stable income.
  • Lease Terms: Secure, long-term leases with fixed annual increases.
  • Debt Management: Low leverage in downturns, strategic gearing in upturns.
  • Active Management: Enhancing income through proactive asset management
AcquisitionRisk MitigationProactive Management
Recovery

Undervalued assets with strong tenants

Tenant covenant strength

Position for uplift

Expansion

Yield enhancement & lease security

Avoid over-leveraging

Active lease management

Hypersupply

Defensive income

Re-leasing risk

Tenant retention strategy

Recession

Capital preservation via income

Cash flow consistency

Seek value opportunities


Understanding these four phases has helped us align our investment strategy with current market conditions, manage risk proactively, and deploy capital at the right time. Our conservative, cycle-aware approach to investing in neighbourhood shopping centres has delivered consistent returns and capital growth through multiple economic cycles.

Your Name

Please enter your full name.

Please enter your email so we can get in touch.

Your Name 

Please enter your email so we can get in touch.

`